Best Practices for Running Employment Background Checks
20 August 2025
Share this article:
In today’s fast paced hiring environment, making confident and informed decisions is more critical than ever. Employment background checks help ensure that your candidates meet your standards and align with your company’s safety, trust, and compliance expectations. But with complex regulations, evolving technologies, and diverse candidate backgrounds, conducting background checks the right way requires diligence, expertise, and the right tools.
This guide provides comprehensive best practices for running employment background checks effectively and compliantly, whether you are a Consumer Reporting Agency or an employer aiming to strengthen your workforce screening process.
Why Employment Background Checks Are Important
Employment background checks serve as a cornerstone of responsible hiring. They help organizations
- Verify the integrity of candidate supplied information
- Identify potential risks or liabilities
- Maintain compliance with industry specific regulations
- Protect company assets and reputation
- Create a safer workplace for employees and customers
A well run background screening program minimizes legal exposure while promoting a culture of transparency and accountability. For Consumer Reporting Agencies, providing clients with high quality
verified public record data builds trust and improves client retention.
How to Conduct Employment Background Checks Effectively
Effective employment background checks require more than just a database search. They involve thoughtful planning, compliance awareness, and access to high
quality public records.
Types of Background Checks
Not all background checks are the same. The type of screening selected should align with the job's responsibilities, industry regulations, and the organization’s internal risk management standards. Common types include
- Criminal background checks to identify felony or misdemeanor convictions
- Employment and education verification to validate resume claims
- Credit reports for roles involving financial responsibility
- Motor vehicle records for positions involving driving
- Professional license verification for regulated industries
- Drug testing where permitted or required
Choosing the appropriate checks ensures a more targeted and legally defensible screening process.
When to Run Background Checks
Timing is critical. Background checks are typically conducted after a conditional job offer has been extended. This approach complies with the Fair Credit Reporting Act and many Ban the Box laws that restrict inquiries into criminal history early in the hiring process.
However, in certain sectors like healthcare, finance, and transportation, continuous or periodic rescreening is also a best practice. This helps ensure ongoing compliance, especially for roles with access to sensitive data or
vulnerable populations.
For current employees, always provide notice and obtain consent before running additional checks, as required under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Staying Compliant with Federal and State Laws
Compliance is foundational to any background check program. Federal laws like the Fair Credit Reporting Act and guidance from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission establish key rules regarding consent, adverse action, and nondiscriminatory use of information.
In addition, state and local laws may place limits on
- Reporting of certain criminal convictions
- Use of credit history in employment decisions
- Marijuana-related offenses, especially in legalized states
- The time frame for how far back certain records can be reported
For instance, California Senate Bill 809 restricts the reporting of certain convictions and mandates individualized assessments before denial based on criminal history.
Working with a knowledgeable screening partner like Eagle Eye Screening Solutions helps you stay informed and compliant across all jurisdictions.
What an Employment Background Check Can Reveal
Criminal History
One of the most requested checks, criminal background searches may include
- Felony and misdemeanor convictions
- Arrest records where permissible
- Pending cases
- Warrants
- Sex offender registry status
Accessing real time court data available through Eagle Eye Screening’s wholesale public record retrieval ensures this information is accurate and legally reportable.
Employment and Education Verification
Verification services confirm the accuracy of a candidate’s resume
- Past employers and job titles
- Dates of employment
- Educational degrees, institutions, and graduation dates
Verifying this information helps detect fraud and confirms that
candidates meet role qualifications.
Credit and Financial History
Credit checks are commonly used for positions involving financial decision making or fiduciary duties. These checks can uncover
- Credit score and payment history
- Bankruptcies and liens
- Collections and charge offs
Keep in mind that many states restrict when and how credit reports can be used in hiring decisions.
Driving Records and Professional Licenses
For roles involving driving such as delivery, trucking, or field services, checking motor vehicle records is essential. These records reveal
- License status
- Traffic violations
- Driving under the influence or suspensions
Professional license checks confirm the validity of required certifications such as nursing licenses, legal credentials, or real estate permits.
Best Practices for Running Multiple Background Checks Regularly
Ongoing monitoring is increasingly becoming a best practice in many industries. To streamline this process and reduce risk, consider the following operational best practices
Standardize Your Screening Process
Develop and document a consistent screening policy that aligns with your organization’s risk tolerance and compliance requirements. This policy should
- Define screening criteria by job role
- Establish adjudication guidelines
- Outline the process for adverse action, disputes, and reevaluation
This standardization ensures fairness and defensibility in hiring decisions.
Use Automation and Alerts Where Possible
Integrate your background screening process with platforms such as AccioData, Digital Delve, TazWorks, or Deverus to automate routine tasks like
- Candidate communication
- Consent collection
- Status updates
- Result delivery
With Eagle Eye Screening’s real time automation tools, you can also set alerts for recurring checks or license renewals, saving time and reducing human error.
Maintain Confidentiality and Data Security
Background check data is sensitive and protected under data privacy laws. Implement strong data security measures such as
- Role based access controls
- Encrypted data storage and transmission
- Regular audits of data access and use
Ensure third party vendors and data processors are also compliant with Fair Credit Reporting Act, General Data Protection Regulation if applicable, and any relevant state regulations.
Keep Records Organized and Up to Date
Efficient recordkeeping ensures that your organization can respond quickly to
- Disputes or correction requests
- Internal audits
- Regulator inquiries
Implement digital file systems that categorize and track completed background checks, consent forms, and adverse action notices in a compliant and easily searchable format.
Review and Refine Your Process Regularly
Your background screening strategy should evolve with changes in
- Laws and regulations
- Industry standards
- Job market dynamics
- Candidate behavior
Schedule annual reviews of your policies and procedures, incorporating insights from compliance officers, hiring managers, and legal advisors.
Choosing a Trusted Background Screening Partner
If you are a Consumer Reporting Agency or an employer managing your own screening process, your choice of background screening partner significantly affects the quality, speed, and compliance of your checks.
Look for providers that offer
- Wholesale public records access with real time court data
- High accuracy and low turnaround times
- Technology integration with your existing platforms such as AccioData, TazWorks, and others
- Responsive customer support and compliance expertise
At Eagle Eye Screening Solutions, we deliver accurate and actionable data from trusted sources nationwide. Our platform connects you to automated county court searches, and our team of industry experts ensures every report meets legal and operational standards.
Ready to Improve Your Employment Background Screening?
Eagle Eye Screening Solutions is your trusted partner for wholesale public record retrieval. Whether you are a Consumer Reporting Agency or a business looking to enhance your screening process, we provide fast, reliable, and compliant background check data tailored to your needs.
Connect with Us:
